Saturday, October 15, 2011

Picture This and That: Look at Dat Glass Edition

Photographic lenses, or "glass" in photographer slang, are something a lot of first-time interchangeable lens camera buyers don't really think about when they make their purchase.  But they should.  In a previous post I said, "there is no point in buying a $1000 receiver and $400 pair of speakers" because bad speakers will degrade source material no matter how good the receiver is.  A better analogy would have been, "there is no point in buying a $2000 mixing board and plugging in $15 microphones" because cameras and lenses are visual recording instruments.  There may be times when a person would want to use a low-fidelity input device such as a cheap microphone or a plastic camera lens because of the effect it gives.  But the same effect can usually be done in processing (mixing or editing), whereas upgrading to a clean picture or recording is difficult or impossible.  Photographers usually aim to get the clearest image possible for that reason.

Below are my notes about lenses.

Basic terminology - these are some frequently used terms.
  • Extension tube - mounts between a body and lens to decrease the focal length
  • Fast - a lens with a large maximum aperture, generally considered to be f/1.4 to f/2.8 depending on the type of lens, but exotic (read: expensive) lenses can be faster
  • Filter - blocks a certain portion of incoming light from passing through it; generally screws onto the end of the lens, but some lenses have a filter tray near the middle of the lens barrel
  • Fisheye - a lens with a very wide field of view and exaggerated distortion
  • Fixed-focus - typically used only on very low-end cameras
  • Kit - a lens that comes with the camera, often a 28-85mm zoom
  • Macro - a lens that allows for close-up work, with minimal magnification
  • Macro filter - not a filter; mounts on the end of lens to allow close-up work
  • Portrait - a slightly long-focus lens, with a focal length of 85mm to 105mm
  • Prime - fixed focal-length lens
  • Standard or normal - a lens that gives a field of view similar to the human eye, typically 50mm for 35mm cameras, with a range from 40mm to 55mm
  • Teleconverter - mounts between a body and lens to increase the focal length
  • Telephoto - a long-focus lens that enlarges distant subjects, with a focal length of 105mm or greater
  • Teleside converter - mounts on the front of a lens to increase the focal length
  • Tilt-shift or perspective control - specialty lens used by professionals
  • Wide-angle - a lens that allows for a greater field of view, with a focal length of 35mm or less
  • Zoom - a variable focal length lens
OEM manufactures - Lenses from camera manufacturers are generally considered to be, on average, better than the third party manufacturers.  None make lenses for any mount but their own, but the lenses can sometimes be re-used with an adapter.
OEM/Third-party manufacturers - both of these companies make their own cameras and lenses, like the ones above.  In the case of Leica, which is widely considered to be the best lens maker in the world, its lenses are often used on other cameras via an adapter.  Sigma started out as a third-party manufacturer, and usually is considered the best.  It recently created its own line of DSLRs with the unique Foveon sensor.
  • Leica - S mount and M mount lenses
  • Sigma - SA mount lenses, plus it is one of the "big three" third-party makers
Third-party manufacturers - these companies make lenses with a variety of mounts.  The lenses are mostly manual focus because until recently the OEM companies did not released the electrical specifications for their lens mounts.  Some companies have reverse-engineered electrical specifications, with mixed results.
  • Tokina - one of the "big three" third-party makers
  • Tamron - one of the "big three" third-party makers
  • Samyang - Korean manufacturer that makes lenses for a lot of rebranders
  • Zeiss - high-end lenses
  • Schneider - tilt-shift lenses
  • Hartblei - tilt-shift lenses
  • Arax - tilt-shift and fisheye lenses
  • Voigtländer - Cosina makes lenses under this name
  • LZOS - Russia company selling two fisheyes
  • KMZ - Russia company with several lenses, usually branded Zenitar
  • Belomo - Belorussian company with several lenses
  • Kowa - makes only one telephoto lens that can also be used as a sighting scope
  • Noktor - fast (large aperture) lens made for SLR Magic
  • Rodenstock, Schneider, Fujinon, and Nikon are the main large-format lens manufacturers
  • Congo, Osaka, Cooke Optics, and perhaps other very low volume manufacturers also make large format lenses
Third-party rebranders - these companies generally just re-badge lenses designed and built by other companies.
  • Vivitar - for a long time this was the largest rebrander in the US.  It sometimes even had its own lens designs made by others.  It seems to have stopped making lenses, though they are still available from some retailer
  • Rokinon - lenses mostly seem to be Samyang
  • Promaster - Wolf Camera "house" brand
  • Pro Optic - may be Adorama "house" brand; lenses mostly seem to be Samyang
  • Bower - may be B&H "house" brand; lenses mostly seem to be Samyang
  • Quantary - Ritz Camera "house" brand
  • Phoenix - Samyang captive brand
  • Opteka - may be 47th Street Photo "house" brand; lenses mostly seem to be Samyang
  • Kenko - Tokina lenses are sometimes sold under this captive brand
  • and probably others around the world; historically there have been hundreds of such brands 
  • Sinar, Linhof, and Caltar apparently rebrand large-format lenses
Specialty and novelty manufacturers - several companies offer lenses that create certain retro or low-fidelity effects, or that have limited appeal for some reason.
MSC lenses - this is a chart of lenses available, or announced and likely to appear, for mirrorless system cameras as of October 2011.  It contains all lenses with a native physical mount, though some are not electrically compatible and thus have to be manually controlled.  The Micro Four-Thirds mount has the most lenses available, though a lot of them are rough duplicates because there are two companies making cameras for the mount.  However, at any particular focal length, one of the lenses may be a better than the other, so it is worth looking at the reviews for both brands.  I think it's unlikely that there will ever be any quality third-party lenses for the Q mount, and perhaps the CX mount as well, because of the small sensor size.  On the other hand, the E mount will eventually attract several third-party makers because the NEX platform is likely to be moderately successful, and Sony has offered to license the electrical specification for the mount.  Samsung seems to have realized that as a very minor player, one of the ways it could get more attention is to field a large array of lenses for the NX mount in short order, which it has.  Focal distances are listed both at the native crop factor and as 35mm-equivalent.


MountBrandNameTypeAFFD MinFD MaxEq. MinEq. Max
CXNikonNikkor 10mm f/2.8 Wide
prime
Yes10102727
CXNikonNikkor VR 10-30mm f/3.5-5.6Standard
zoom
Yes10302781
CXNikonNikkor VR 10-100mm f/4.5-5.6 PD-zoom Super
zoom
Yes1010027270
CXNikonNikkor VR 30-110mm f/3.8-5.6 Telephoto
zoom
Yes3011081297
ERokinon8mm Ultra wide Angle f/3.5 Fisheye LensFisheye
prime
No881212
ESony16mm f/2.8
wide-Angle Lens
Wide
prime
Yes16162424
ESony18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 Zoom LensStandard
zoom
Yes18552783
ESony18-200mm f/3.5-6.3 Zoom LensSuper
zoom
Yes1820027300
ESonyCarl Zeiss 24mm f/1.8 LensWide
prime
Yes24243636
ESony30mm f/3.5 Macro LensNormal
prime
Yes30304545
ESony50mm f/1.8 Telephoto LensTelephoto primeYes50507575
ESony55-210mm Zoom LensTelephoto
zoom
Yes5521083315
ENoktorHyperPrime 50mm f/0.95Telephoto primeNo50507575
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario 7-14mm F4.0 Asph.Wide
zoom
Yes7141428
mFTSamyang7.5mm 1:3.5 UMC Fisheye MFTFisheye
prime
No881515
mFTPanasonicLumix G Fisheye 8mm F3.5 Fisheye
prime
Yes881616
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 9-18mm F4.0-5.6Wide
zoom
Yes9181836
mFTWanderlustPinwideSpecialty
lens
No11112222
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 12mm F2.0 Wide
prime
Yes12122424
mFTPanasonicLumix G 14mm F2.5 Asph. Wide
prime
Yes14142828
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 14-42mm F3.5-5.6Standard
zoom
Yes14422884
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital 14-42mm F3.5-5.6 IIStandard
zoom
Yes14422884
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital 14-42mm F3.5-5.6 II RStandard
zoom
Yes14422884
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario 14-42mm F3.5-5.6 Asph. Mega O.I.S.Standard
zoom
Yes14422884
mFTPanasonicLumix G X Vario PZ 14-42mm F3.5-5.6 Asph. Power O.I.S.Standard
zoom
Yes14422884
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario 14-45mm F3.5-5.6 Asph. Mega O.I.S.Standard
zoom
Yes14452890
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario HD 14-140mm F4.0-5.8 Asph. Mega O.I.SSuper
zoom
Yes1414028280
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 14-150mm F4.0-5.6Super
zoom
Yes1415028300
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital 17mm F2.8 Wide
prime
Yes17173434
mFTPanasonicLumix G 20mm F1.7 Asph. Wide
prime
Yes20204040
mFTPanasonicLeica DG Summilux 25mm F1.4 Asph. Normal
prime
Yes25255050
mFTVoigtlanderNokton 25mm F0.95Normal
prime
No25255050
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm F4.0-5.6Telephoto
zoom
Yes4015080300
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 40-150mm F4.0-5.6 RTelephoto
zoom
Yes4015080300
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital 45mm F1.8 Telephoto primeYes45459090
mFTPanasonicLeica DG Macro-Elmarit 45mm F2.8 Asph. Mega O.I.S.Telephoto primeYes45459090
mFTPanasonicLumix G X Vario PZ 45-175mm F4.0-5.6 Asph. Power O.I.S.Telephoto
zoom
Yes4517590350
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario 45-200mm F4.0-5.6 Mega O.I.STelephoto
zoom
Yes4520090400
mFTNoktorHyperPrime 50mm f/0.95Telephoto primeNo5050100100
mFTOlympusM.Zuiko Digital ED 75-300mm F4.8-6.7Telephoto
zoom
Yes75300150600
mFTPanasonicLumix G Vario 100-300mm F4.0-5.6 Mega O.I.STelephoto
zoom
Yes100300200600
NXSamyang8mm F3.5 Fisheye Fisheye
prime
No881212
NXSamyang14mm F2.8 IF ED MC Aspherical Wide
prime
No14142121
NXSamsung16mm F2.4 PancakeWide
prime
Yes16162424
NXSamsung16-80mm F3.5-4.5 OIS Standard
zoom
Yes168024120
NXSamsung18-55mm Portrait Lens Standard
zoom
Yes18552783
NXSamsungCompact 18-55mm Zoom Lens Standard
zoom
Yes18552783
NXSamsung18-200mm Multi-Purpose Lens Super
zoom
Yes1820027300
NXSamsung20mm NX Pancake LensWide
prime
Yes20203030
NXSamsungUltra Compact 20-50mm Zoom Lens Standard
zoom
Yes20503075
NXSamyang24mm f/1.4 ED AS UMC Wide
prime
No24243636
NXSamsung30mm NX Pancake Lens Normal
prime
Yes30304545
NXSamyang35mm F1.4 AS UMC Normal
prime
No35355353
NXSamsung50-200mm Telephoto Zoom Lens Telephoto
zoom
Yes5020075300
NXSamsung50-200mm NX Telephoto OIS Lens Telephoto
zoom
Yes5020075300
NXSamsung60mm F2.8 Macro ED OIS SSATelephoto primeYes60609090
NXSamsung85mm F1.4 ED SSATelephoto primeYes8585128128
NXSamyang85mm F1.4 Aspherical IF Telephoto primeNo8585128128
QPentaxFish-Eye 3.2mm f/5.6Fisheye
prime
No331818
QPentaxStandard
zoom 5-15mm f/2.8-4.5
Standard
zoom
Yes5152884
QPentaxToy Lens
wide 6.3mm f/7.1
Specialty
lens
No663535
QPentaxStandard Prime 8.5mm f/1.9 AL [IF]Normal
prime
Yes994848
QPentaxToy Lens Telephoto 18mm f/8Specialty
lens
No1818101101

No comments: